Fix or Replace? calculator
Fix or Replace? DIY, a Repair Shop or a New One
Pick a device and what is wrong with it. The calculator sets the cost of doing it yourself (the part, the tools and your time) beside a repair shop’s price and a new or certified refurbished replacement, gives a verdict, and opens the repair in 3D with the trap that costs the most.
67 devices · 93 faults · 58 guides with sourced prices
No device matches that search.
iPhone 16 Battery & Back Glass Teardown
Apple’s own repair service
Costliest trap · step 9Levering the battery out with metala screwdriver under its edge bends and pierces the foil pouch: it can smoke and catch fire
Open the 3D guide →Figures are estimates in US dollars, read on makers’ and shops’ own pages in October 2026 and November 2026; they vary by shop and country, and the pages are listed with the guide’s sources. How the verdict works: our own rules of thumb, not statistics. DIY wins when the 3D risk is low or medium and doing it yourself saves over 40% against a replacement (against a shop’s price where buying new does not apply). Replace instead when the device is sealed or potted, or the repair costs over 60% of a replacement. Consider a shop when the risk is high, the job needs soldering or it has a delicate ribbon-cable trap. Your time counts at the rate you pick. The links open a shop search; we earn nothing from them.
Questions
How does the calculator decide?
By our own rules of thumb, not statistics. DIY wins when the 3D risk level is low or medium and doing it yourself saves over 40% against a replacement (against a shop’s price where buying new does not apply, as for upkeep). Replace instead when the device is sealed or potted, or the repair you would choose costs over 60% of a replacement. Consider a repair shop when the risk is high, the job needs soldering or it has a delicate ribbon-cable trap.
Where do the prices come from?
Each figure is an estimate read on a maker’s or a shop’s own page, with the month it was checked, and the page is listed with the sources on the repair’s own page. Prices vary by shop and country. Where we found no fair figure, the calculator shows none and gives no verdict it cannot back.
What does “your time is worth” change?
It adds the job’s hours to the cost of doing it yourself: nothing at $0/hr (a hobby), or $25 or $50 for each hour. A long job can then cost more than a shop.
Why does a device have no verdict?
A figure is missing: no published part or replacement price, a generic model of our own design with no single price, or upkeep with no sourced shop price to compare with.
Why is a replacement sometimes pre-owned?
For a phone its maker no longer sells, new or certified refurbished, we give a shop’s own price for a pre-owned one where we found it, and say so; where we found none, the calculator shows no replacement price.
Do you store what I pick or type?
No. The search box only filters the list in your browser. Nothing you pick or type is stored in your browser or sent to us.
Are the shop links recommendations?
No. A repair-shop link opens a Google Maps search near you: we do not check, rate or recommend the shops it shows. Part and refurbished-price links are plain searches on Amazon, eBay and iFixit.
Guides with no sourced price yet
These guides give no verdict until a fair figure is found on a maker’s or a shop’s own page:
- Google Pixel 8 Battery Replacement in 3D
- Smartphone Screen and Battery Teardown
- Jump-Start a Car with a Flat Battery
- Build a Gaming PC
- How a Click Pen Works
- How a Zipper Works
- How a Sewing Machine Makes a Lockstitch
- How a Car Differential Works: Ring, Pinion and Spiders
- How a Four-Stroke Engine Works
- Tesla Model 3 & Model Y Door Panel and Speaker Repair